I like waterproof eyeliners best.
Why? Because, typically, those are the only ones that even stand a chance at staying put on my lid, much less my waterline (the inner rim of your eye).
I won't even waste my time with non-waterproof versions.
Well, I got a waterproof eyeliner in my
Glossybox not too long ago, so I excitedly tried it out.
The details: Elite Paris Intensity Waterproof "Long Lasting Eye Pencil", Made in France, in Mysterious Black 01.
I won't bore you with a bunch of words.
Let me just show you in pictures why this liner is "fail".
Notice that the waterline that I lined doesn't really look as if it ever were lined?
Honestly, so far I've not had luck with eyeliner pencils at all, though I haven't tried lots of waterproof ones. I've mostly used the waterproof marker types with success on the lids, but not on the waterline. I guess pencil liners don't like me.
Have you found a great liner for the waterline? Or an inexpensive pencil liner that really, truly stays put? Do share!